Women's Suffrage

In the 19th century, female property holders could demand municipal voting rights on the principle of "no taxation without representation." Propertied women in Québec voted unchallenged between 1809 and 1849, when the word "male" was inserted into Québec's franchise act. What Québec women lost, Ontario women soon gained: from 1850, women with property, married or single, could vote for school trustees. By 1900 municipal voting privileges for propertied women were general throughout Canada. But most 19th-century Canadians, women as well as men, believed that the sexes had been assigned to "separate spheres" by natural and divine laws that overrode mere man-made laws, and this stood squarely in the way of achieving votes for all women as a democratic right.

Keywords

Women

At the provincial level, public debate in Ontario began among members of the Toronto Women's Literary Club, a screen for suffrage activities created 1876 by Dr Emily Howard STOWE, Canada's first woman doctor. She and her daughter, Dr Augusta STOWE-GULLEN, spearheaded Ontario's suffrage campaign for 40 years. In 1883 the club became the Toronto Women's Suffrage Association, then in 1889 the Dominion Women's Enfranchisement Association - a national group in name only.

Despite numerous petitions and bills, Ontario's lawmakers, confident that they had public opinion behind them, repeatedly blocked changes. Suffrage groups were thus forced to undertake long years of public education. Valuable support came in the 1890s from the WOMAN'S CHRISTIAN TEMPERANCE UNION, whose leaders saw votes for women as necessary in achieving PROHIBITION. In 1910, the respected and influential NATIONAL COUNCIL OF WOMEN spoke out for suffrage.

Macphail, Agnes
Macphail was the only woman in Canada to be elected to the House of Commons in 1921, the first year in which women had the vote (courtesy Library and Archives Canada).

McClung, Murphy and Jamieson
Nellie McClung (left), Emily Murphy (right) and Laura Jamieson (March 1916) were the leaders of the feminist cause in western Canada (courtesy City of Edmonton Archives).

Hind, Cora
An early suffragette, at 75 Hind travelled around the world to observe agricultural methods (courtesy PAM).

Dominant Figures

The WCTU was also active in Manitoba, where women's suffrage had first been proposed in 1870 by the Icelandic community. Among Manitoba's early leaders were Mrs M.J. Benedictssen, Mrs A.V. Thomas, Dr Amelia Yeomans and Mrs J.A. McClung. McClung's daughter-in-law, Nellie MCCLUNG, later became the Prairie movement's dominant figure. Between 1912 and 1915 there was a sharp, concerted campaign. Then on 28 January 1916 Manitoba women became the first in Canada to win the rights to vote and to hold provincial office. They were followed by Saskatchewan on March 14 and Alberta on April 19. BC approved women's suffrage on 5 April 1917, and Ontario suffragists, after many years of struggle, celebrated their hard-won victory on April 12.

Meanwhile, pressure was mounting on federal politicians. In the controversial WARTIME ELECTIONS ACT of 1917, the federal vote was extended to women in the armed forces, and to female relatives of military men. At the same time thousands of loyal citizens naturalized after 1902 were disenfranchised. It was not an honourable victory for Canadian women.

On 24 May 1918 all female citizens aged 21 and over became eligible to vote in federal elections, regardless of whether they had yet attained the provincial franchise. In July 1919 they gained the complementary right to stand for the House of Commons, although appointment to the Senate remained out of reach until after the PERSONS CASE of 1929. Throughout the preceding debates, the compelling argument in women's favour was their service, sacrifice and proven competence during WWI - just as Prairie women had gained provincial rights largely on their record in helping to settle and build the country. Although democratic right did have a place in the argument, service was the keynote.

The provincial franchise for Nova Scotia women came on 26 April 1918, after a lacklustre campaign. The cause was even less popular in New Brunswick, which approved women's suffrage on 17 April 1919. PEI, with practically no popular agitation, changed its franchise Act on 3 May 1922, and Newfoundland women gained the vote on 13 April 1925. In Nova Scotia, PEI and Newfoundland, the right to stand for provincial office accompanied voting rights, but New Brunswick avoided that radical step until 9 March 1934. In Québec, under the courageous leadership of Thérèse CASGRAIN, the struggle continued until 25 April 1940, when women finally achieved the provincial counterpart to the federal vote they had been exercising for over 20 years.

Reason and Quiet Persistence

Mock Parliament at Walker Theatre
An advertisement for the mock parliament held at Walker Theatre, January 1914, in which Nellie McClung took part and helped advanced the cause of women's suffrage (courtesy Government of Canada).

Compared to the flamboyance and occasional violence of British, French and American suffrage campaigns, Canada's was peaceable and urbane, with humour, reason and quiet persistence. Increasing numbers of women are found in politics. As of 1996, the greatest number of women (52) had been elected to the House of Commons and the greatest number (8) subsequently became Cabinet ministers. A total of 24 women had been appointed to the senate. Canadian women only began to consider careers in politics seriously in the 1970s, having learned in the preceding half century that winning the vote was only a first step in a movement, far from over, for fundamental political and social change.

Author SUSAN JACKEL

Links to Other Sites

First Women in Provincial and Territorial Legislatures
This Library and Archives Canada website is dedicated to pioneering women politicians in Canada. Produced in recognition of Women's History Month.

Democracy 250
This extensive website chronicles the history of parliamentary democracy in Nova Scotia, beginning with the landmark Halifax meeting of the Nova Scotia House of Assembly in 1758. Offers a timeline, archival material, and an online guide to Democracy 250 celebrations.

Canadian Women in the Book Trade
This Library and Archives Canada website features profiles of prominent women in the Canadian publishing industry. Also includes bibliographies and teaching guides.

The Famous Five
This website focuses on the Famous Five and their struggle to advance the legal rights of Canadian women. From the Heritage Community Foundation in Alberta.

Women at Work
"Women at Work" looks at the changing and expanding horizons for New Brunswick women from the late 1800's to the late 1900's - by focusing on the work engaged in by women, paid or unpaid. From The Provincial Archives of New Brunswick.

Canadian Women's History
A Parks Canada website in honour of Canadian women, their struggles for equality and their innumerable contributions to Canadian society.

Changing Women, Changing History: Canadian Women
This Library and Archives Canada site features biographies of women activists who have made substantial contributions to the lives of all Canadian women. Also offers teaching guides and reference sources.

Glossary: Famous 5
A glossary of terms relating to events and issues concerning attempts by women to attain respect and recognition in the early years of the 20th Century. From the website "The Famous Five."

Gallery of Greats
This site features an illustrated history of Canadian women and their accomplishments. Includes learning materials for students and their teachers. From the Government of Ontario.

Ten Thousand Roses
An excerpt from "Ten Thousand Roses," a book about the "making of a feminist revolution." From Penguin Group (Canada.)

CPAC
CPAC, the Cable Public Affairs Channel, provides a window on Parliament, politics, and public affairs in Canada. Click on "Telling Times" to view a series of short historical documentaries that showcase pivotal Canadian events.

Canadian Women's Christian Temperance Union Fonds
An overview of the history of the Canadian Women's Christian Temperance Union, an organization that fought to expand the role of women in Canadian society. From the Archives of Ontario website.

Feature Articles

The Birth of the National Hockey League

The formation of the National Hockey League was not a big deal in the life of Canada in 1917...